A race against time to save Alpine ice cores that record medieval mining, fires, and volcanoes - Earth - Earth Sciences - Environment

Researchers of the Ca' Foscari University of Venice and the Austrian Academy of Science drill an ice core at Weißseespitze, Ötztal Alps, in 2018. Credit: Prof Andrea Fischer

Ice cores taken from glaciers reveal the air pollution of the past, using atmospheric particles incorporated in snow that fell on the glacier and became ice. Now, scientists have extracted a record of thousands of years' worth of air pollution from 9.5 meters of ice at the Weißseespitze glacier, close to the border between Austria and Italy. But this ice is under threat from global warming, and scientists warn that it is now a race against time to capture critical climate information locked in these glaciers before it's gone forever.

"These remarkable climate archives function much like a history book: past atmospheric conditions and environmental changes are recorded in their layers," said Dr. Azzurra Spagnesi of the University Ca' Foscari of Venice, lead author of the article in Frontiers in Earth Science.

"Alpine glaciers offer a unique opportunity to investigate the critical transition between pre-industrial and industrial times, because of their proximity to human settlements."

Frozen in time

In 2019, the team visited Weißseespitze and drilled down to the bedrock to take an ice core nearly 10 meters long. They used argon isotope data to estimate the age of its layers, showing that the surface of the glacier formed between 1552 and 1708 CE, while the deepest layer dated back to 349 BCE and 420 CE.

Then they analyzed the core for traces of 18 different elements, microcharcoal, levoglucosan—a chemical compound that forms when wood burns—and carboxylic and dicarboxylic acids.

The summit of Weißseespitze in 2023. The dark surface shows significant melting. Credit: Prof Andrea Fischer

"Between 700 and 1200 CE, lead and other metals showed very low concentrations, reflecting the regional background of a mostly unpolluted pre-industrial environment," explained Spagnesi. "From roughly 950 CE onward, peaks in arsenic, lead, copper, and silver appear, corresponding to periods of intensified medieval mining and smelting in the Alps and other European regions."

"Some of the strongest metal peaks also coincide with major volcanic eruptions, as well as periods of dry climate and increased dust transport," Spagnesi added. "This suggests that both natural events and human activities contributed to the chemical signals preserved in the ice."

The scientists found a striking peak in chemical pollution between approximately 902 and 1280 CE. They compared this to the levels of microcharcoal found in cores of peat taken from nearby swampy areas and found matching peaks, which confirms that fires were more common and more intense in this region during this period.

"The elevated fire signal we observe during the roughly century-long drought between about 950 and 1040 CE is likely the result of several interacting factors," said Spagnesi.

"Such dry conditions can promote cycles of vegetation growth followed by desiccation, creating highly flammable landscapes that are more prone to burning.

"At the same time, human activity in Alpine regions appears to have intensified. Historical and paleoenvironmental evidence points to increased grassland management, agricultural expansion, and land clearing, all of which commonly involved fire. Periods of conflict may have contributed locally, either through deliberate burning or accidental ignitions."

"However, although the age–depth scale was substantially improved by adding 39Ar dating to the radiocarbon constraints previously used, the remaining uncertainties are still relatively large," cautioned Spagnesi. "This makes it more challenging to link individual chemical peaks to specific events."

Melting away

At Weißseespitze, local mining and other human activities drove peaks in pollution, while natural factors like volcanoes amplified them. But anthropogenic emissions can only account for about 7% of the air pollution recorded in the ice core.

Emissions caused by humans appear as peaks against a comparatively stable, natural background—which is sadly not the case today.

The scientists have continued to return to Weißseespitze for research. But alarmingly, a visit to the drilling site in 2025 showed that the ice was now only 5.5 meters deep. Unless we act now to sample these disappearing glaciers, the information they carry will be lost.

"Glaciers in the Ötztal Alps are projected to disappear within the coming decades," said Spagnesi.

"If glaciers disappear, the chemical and physical information they contain will be lost forever, leaving gaps in our understanding of past climate variability. In this sense, preserving glaciers is not just about protecting ice. It is about safeguarding the memory of Earth's climate." 

Provided by Frontiers 

by Frontiers

edited by Sadie Harley, reviewed by Robert Egan 

Source: A race against time to save Alpine ice cores that record medieval mining, fires, and volcanoes