Social
grooming between two chimpanzees in the Budongo Forest. Photograph by Dr.
Elodie Freymann. Credit: Dr. Elodie Freymann
Scientists studying chimpanzees in
Budongo Forest, Uganda, have observed that these primates don't just treat
their own injuries, but care for others, too—information which could shed light
on how our ancestors first began treating wounds and using medicines.
Although chimpanzees elsewhere have
been observed helping other community members with medical problems, the persistent presence of this behavior in Budongo could suggest
that medical care among chimpanzees is much more widespread than
we realized, and not confined to care for close relatives.
"Our research helps illuminate
the evolutionary roots of human medicine and health care systems," said
Dr. Elodie Freymann of the University of Oxford, first author of the article
in Frontiers in Ecology and Evolution. "By documenting how
chimpanzees identify and utilize medicinal plants and provide care to others, we gain insight into
the cognitive and social foundations of human health care behaviors."
Community care
The scientists studied two communities of chimpanzees in the Budongo Forest—Sonso and Waibira. Like all chimpanzees, members of these communities are vulnerable to injuries, whether caused by fights, accidents, or snares set by humans. About 40% of all individuals in Sonso have been seen with snare injuries.
A young chimpanzee cares for a wound on his left
knee with chewed stem bark and fresh leaves, filmed by Dr. Elodie Freymann.
Credit: Dr. Elodie Freymann
The researchers spent four months
observing each community, as well as drawing on video
evidence from the
Great Ape Dictionary database, logbooks containing decades of observational
data, and a survey of other scientists who had witnessed chimpanzees treating
illness or injury.
Any plants chimpanzees were seen
using for external care were identified; several turned out to have chemical
properties which could improve wound healing and relevant traditional medicine uses.
During their direct observational
periods, the scientists recorded 12 injuries in Sonso, all of which were likely
caused by within-group conflicts. In Waibira, five chimpanzees were injured—one
female by a snare, and four males in fights. The researchers also identified
more cases of care in Sonso than in Waibira.
"This likely stems from
several factors, including possible differences in social hierarchy stability
or greater observation opportunities in the more thoroughly habituated Sonso
community," said Freymann.
The roots of modern medicine?
The researchers documented 41 cases
of care overall: seven cases of care for others—prosocial care—and 34 cases of
self-care. These cases often included several different care behaviors, which
might be treating different aspects of a wound, or might reflect a chimpanzee's
personal preferences.
"Chimpanzee wound care
encompasses several techniques: direct wound licking, which removes debris and
potentially applies antimicrobial compounds in saliva; finger licking followed
by wound pressing; leaf-dabbing; and chewing plant materials and applying them
directly to wounds," said Freymann.
"All chimpanzees mentioned in
our tables showed recovery from wounds, though, of course, we don't know what
the outcome would have been had they not done anything about their injuries.
"We also documented hygiene
behaviors, including the cleaning of genitals with leaves after mating and
wiping the anus with leaves after defecation—practices that may help prevent
infections."
Who cares?
Of the seven instances of prosocial
care, the researchers found four cases of wound treatment, two cases of snare
removal assistance, and one case where a chimpanzee helped another with
hygiene. Care wasn't preferentially given by, or provided to, one sex or age
group. On four occasions, care was given to genetically unrelated individuals.
"These behaviors add to the
evidence from other sites that chimpanzees appear to recognize need or
suffering in others and take deliberate action to alleviate it, even when
there's no direct genetic advantage," said Freymann.
The
scientists call for more research into the social and ecological contexts in
which care takes place, and which individuals give and receive care. One
possibility is that the high risk of injury and death which Budongo chimpanzees
all face from snares could increase the likelihood that these chimpanzees care for each other's wounds, but we need more
data to explore this.
"Our study has a few methodological
limitations," cautioned Freymann.
"The difference in habituation
between the Sonso and Waibira communities creates an observation bias,
particularly for rare behaviors like prosocial health care. While we documented
plants used in health care contexts, further pharmacological analyses are
needed to confirm their specific medicinal properties and efficacy.
"Also, the relative rarity of prosocial health care makes it challenging to identify patterns regarding when and why such care is provided or withheld. These limitations highlight directions for future research in this emerging field."
by Frontiers
Source: Chimpanzees use medicinal leaves to perform first aid, scientists discover
No comments:
Post a Comment